Frieze Live | Passive Aggressive #3

Image courtesy the artists and Southard Reid. Photo: Hugo Glendinning.

The British artist duo Edward Thomasson & Lucy Beech reveal the violence of everyday performativity with their last installment of the non-theatrical 3-part series Passive Aggressive. The piece accentuates how this performativity is not just a gendered diagnostic of the contemporary Corporate Female navigating her way through the aggression of the work-place, but a constructive mode of life. At 2:45 PM daily during the fair in Regent’s Park, a group of six women in professional attire appear on stage to perform a mesmerizing choreography with the sounds of their bodies. Mic’ed on wrists, necks and underwear, what initially feels like a claustrophobic corporatization of the body reveals itself as a form of collective catharsis. One after the other, the smirking women present to each other their self-produced sound effects in an unsettling hybrid of affection and competition.

Edward Thomasson & Lucy Beech met in art school in the early 2000s when they were both skirting around the issue of live work. “We never actually made anything live, I don’t think we had the balls to do it,” Lucy recalls over coffee. “We were treading the same path and approached the same things, but from completely different angles.” Although they never worked together in college, they “did pretty much everything else together,” and when Edward was approached for a project a few years later, they decided to finally collaborate professionally. Interested in the mechanics of performance, they made a choir and a film, amongst others, but with limited success. Ultimately, it was simple 2-minute enactments of team-building games that triggered a real interest in the duo. “It was just an exercise comprised of pushing a balloon between two people. Everything we had spent weeks doing was absolutely terrible, but this thing had legs.” Both trained video artists, the filmic medium now only serves as complimentary to their collaborative performances through single-channel shots documenting their study of the particularities of everyday performativity.

They first began exploring the notion of passive aggression in 2013; looking at their old work they began to think about the mode of performance as a whole. “We began to realize that there is something passively aggressive about the atmosphere of our performances – passive aggression not just within the interpersonal, but actually as a tone,” Edward explains. “We were also thinking about passive aggression as a mode or way of life, and the term really is very indicative of the subjects we are talking about: these moments in life where you are performing under a double-standard,” adds Lucy.

This borderline performativity of everyday behavior is accentuated through Edward and Lucy’s use of amplified sounds of their heavily wired performers, which adds an additional layer of representation to their practice. The meticulous and anxiety-provoking noisy installing and dismantling of microphones serve as the performance’s pre- and postlude and installs a red thread of sonic perception through the piece. Under the veneer of familiar performed female passivity dwells a violence indicative of the oppressiveness of these performativities, not just of theatrical environments or designated spaces of public performance, but in every encounter with oneself and one’s surroundings. “We have a general interest in the fetishisation of the unsaid, engaging the things that can be felt, but not seen,” they explain.

Edward and Lucy’s synthetic style of performance derives as much from therapeutic YouTube tutorials as from conceptual dance; particularly Pina Bauch’s Tanztheater has informed their approach to bodily (non-)expressionism. Still, theatrical behavior for the duo is always object-like and borrowed, immersed in the monotonous setting of the everyday. During Thomasson’s residency in the Outset Artist’s Flat at the South London Gallery, they employed actors as estate agents hosting an ‘open house’ event, thus casting the audience as potential buyers. In their work, the viewer becomes site-specific under the general concern of entertainment, which pushes the conventions for performance-as-spectacle. “Who is the audience and how are the performers using them? It’s quite interesting to engage and really ask the audience to get on board,” they reflect. Here, ‘the theatrical’ transpires to the directly interpersonal.

As opposed to previous work, Passive Aggressive #3 aims to present a narrative instantaneously, as Edward and Lucy try to engage the passive art-collecting audience of the fair. “I think with this one we’ve really pushed it in terms of the theatricality and framing of their gestures,” Edward says. “In a way, we deal with dramaturgy as an object – handing the performers a mode of theatricality.” They specifically cast actors rather than dancers to avoid movement-based forms of expression, and do not consider themselves choreographers. Rather, they work with the principles of choreography and examine their logic and (in)expressions, while extending this knowledge to a larger sphere of movement in non-theatrical environments. “We feel very comfortable using movement that is based on logic, that sets it in place – there’s nothing expressive about it, actually.”

The first installment of Passive Aggressive took place in an empty bank in Istanbul, where the duo worked with a group of eight local theatre students. Paradoxically, the empty space was highly guarded by armed security guards who performed x-rays on visitors prior to entry. The group subsequently allowed this double-standard to sieve in to the work itself: dressed like guards, the participants performed and choreographed a kind of ‘security training’ mimicking the actual guards outside. The second installment followed soon after, in Camden Arts Center in London, and incorporated audio into the performance. After a longer break, the duo met again for the completion of their study of bipolar performance, concluding with an all-woman cast dressed in the quintessential attire of the Corporate Female, evoking the kind of rightwing feminism that sees gender equality as ‘women working like men.’ This includes aggressive forms of (self) management.

“The all-women cast was a parameter for this piece,” Lucy explains: “We initially started thinking about what women do in groups. We were specifically looking at female competitiveness and corporate feminism, and the moment where feminist discourses get appropriated, incorporated and geared towards a model of capitalism. We looked at Sheryl Sandberg’s lean-in circles: these therapeutic groups meeting in order to proliferate or succeed on the level of men, and how this works against itself as feminism bites its own tail.”

The women in Passive Aggressive embody the gendered term with a schizophrenic duality, embodying the mode of expression that is asked of women in a corporate environment: “smiling through gritted teeth,” as Edward puts it. At the same time they celebrate it and find usefulness in it: the irritable sounds of movement in a female office suit lay the foundation for a choreography to the sound Kiesza’s Hideaway. “As they collectively make these sounds that they cannot talk about, they are in a way working through that anxiety,” Edward explains. Much of their work refers directly to therapeutic situations (group circles, work outs, games), using their strategies as a tool of fiction. In that way, the performances simultaneously interrogate the language of represented performativity of the media, from corporate training videos to Pilates DVDs. “We make performance in non-theatrical environments and look at the theatrical frameworks that exist in interpersonal relations,” Lucy explains – “and what happens when you put those thing back in the theatre.” “It’s a bit of a head fuck,” Edward adds. The result, however, is incredibly efficient as these ‘theatrical frameworks’ are instantly-recognizable as something inherent to experiences in all of our lives. As they break away from the architecture of theatre, they confront the audience with levels of performativity that may never have been otherwise witnessed.


Image courtesy the artists and Southard Reid. Photo: Hugo Glendinning.


Image courtesy the artists and Southard Reid. Photo: Hugo Glendinning.


Image courtesy the artists and Southard Reid. Photo: Hugo Glendinning.


Image courtesy the artists and Southard Reid. Photo: Hugo Glendinning.


Image courtesy the artists and Southard Reid. Photo: Hugo Glendinning.


Image courtesy the artists and Southard Reid. Photo: Hugo Glendinning.

Recent Posts


What is a piece of clothing that “works”? Who is working whom? Is the one who poses the one who actually “works” hardest? The S/S 2017 collection of Berlin-based, Swedish- Vietnamese designer NHU DUONG entitled ‘WORK COLLECTION’ plays with the ideas of professionalism, leisure and appropriateness through a range of garments that are inspired by work outfits and hobby uniforms. Overalls, raw denim outfits, kung-fu pyjamas, biker pants, baggy tights and gloves, bomber-jackets, bomber suits,… [read more »]

Preparing to Welcome the Chthulucene | Agustina Zegers

Preparing to Welcome the Chthulucene is a text made up of living exercises to accompany Haraway’s theorization of the Chthulucene and her upcoming book Staying With the Trouble: Making Kin in the Chthulucene. Haraway posits that not only should we name the Anthropocene carefully (including the terms Capitalocene and Plantationocene within its narrative) but that we should also be using this crucial ecological timeframe to move towards a dynamically multi-species, “sym-chtonic“, sym-poietic future: the Chthulucene.… [read more »]

Laboria Cuboniks in Conversation

Laboria Cuboniks is currently a group of 6 women working together online to redefine a feminism adequate to the twenty-first century. They collectively wrote Xenofeminsim: A Politics for Alienation in 2014. Here, in conversation with Postcontemporary Issue guest editors Armen Avanessian and Suhail Malik they discuss the dissatisfactions and limitations of historical feminism and the importance of theorizing “the future” as a feminist project. Armen Avanessian and Suhail Malik: The initial formulation of your political… [read more »]

Situating Global Forms: An Anthropology of Cosmopolitan Science

Aihwa Ong, interviewed by Armen Avanessian and Suhail Malik Constructing Globality Armen Avanessian and Suhail Malik: Your anthropological research pays close attention to specific emerging and inventive configurations of globally-constituted modernization, particularly in East Asia and its diaspora. Throughout this work you identity many ways in which ‘things that used to be fused together — identity, entitlement, territoriality, and nationality — are being taken apart and realigned in innovative relationships and spaces by neoliberal technologies… [read more »]

Ways Of Living ⎮ Arcadia Missa

Ways of Living, curated by the team behind Arcadia Missa, moves beyond the home as a site of political contestation and into the working place, the artist studio, the public sphere, and nature. While so-called ‘social practice’ taught us that any attempt of art to engage with issues outside its own institutional reality are easily coopted into the mythologizing machinery of individualism and patriarchy, art still possesses an ability to address issues far beyond the… [read more »]

What is at Stake in the Future? | Alex Williams & Nick Srnicek

Every ‘future’ inscribes a demand upon the present. This is so whether at the level of human imagination, or within the sphere of political or aesthetic action necessary to reach towards their realisation. Futures make explicit the implicit contents of our own times, crystallising trajectories, tendencies, projects, theories and contingencies. Moreover, futures map the absent within the present, the presents which could never come into actuality, the wreckage of dreams past and desires vanquished. Futures… [read more »]

Dog Plays | Hayley Silverman

Hayley Silverman’s “Dog Plays,” an ongoing series in which a cast of untrained dogs take on the role of characters from a range of pop-culture texts, disrupt the canon of identities traditionally represented in Hollywood as they are re-inhabited by animals. Calling on artifacts ranging from Richard Linklater films, to science-fiction thrillers, to Depression-era musicals that rhapsodize class difference, these performances investigate how our understanding of narrative, authority and identity transforms when we project stories,… [read more »]

A poem by Ser Serpas

ripped apart you rip me apart collage million dead collage donde queda mi cuerpo el temporal como dios en mil partes clothing as point of impact a totem is a wrap around a city as it is engagement with one’s surroundings and engagement with that which has been worn out discarded and filtered into alms buckets and newly tagged i wear my surroundings on my feet when it wears out i see only my vantage… [read more »]

DISCREET Call for Participants

DISCREET – An Intelligence Agency for the People The 9th Berlin Biennale for Contemporary Art invites you to apply for one of fifteen spaces open to individuals interested in taking an active part in a three-week-long public workshop conceived of by Armen Avanessian and Alexander Martos for the formation and development of a civil secret service organization. Held from June 22 to July 11, 2016, the workshop brings together renegade experts from art, theory, technology,… [read more »]

Parent and Parroting | Nancy Lupo

Each year retail displays are readied in preparation for the gestation and labor of the catch-all holiday season before floating into a colorless postnatal celebration of mundane plenty. Capitalism’s sympathetic pregnancy makes for a cold and lifeless pas de deux, at times humorously inseparable from the vitality of social milestones. In Parent and Parroting, Nancy Lupo continues with a series of interventions into commercial products and industrialized food. Her interferences often reveal or reconfigure the… [read more »]